A Study of Ecstasy

One of the many tragedies of language is how badly it fails at accurately conveying the intensity of emotions, sensations, and experiences. ‘Happiness’ can mean a relatively mild state of contentment, and it can also mean a state of:

  • Deep, radical bliss
  • Infinite cosmic harmony
  • Being at one with God or The Universe

And so forth. Worse still, even earnest attempts at distinguishing between experiences of wildly different intensities often fall flat for those who haven’t experienced something comparable.

What’s ‘being one with God’ to someone who has never experienced anything remotely like this? Surely things can’t get that good, can they?

Yes they can, dear reader. Yes they can.

The following is a collection of accounts of ecstatic experiences: states of consciousness so divinely blissful that the subjects of these states would trade many years or decades of normal life for just a few more seconds of said divinity.

In 1961, the English novelist and critic Marghanita Laski published Ecstasy, one of the first attempts to study these experiences systematically. She put a questionnaire to about sixty friends and acquaintances and set their answers beside passages from poets, novelists and mystics. Sixty years earlier, the American psychologist and philosopher William James had gathered similar testimony in The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902). This collection draws on both books.

While humans can’t visualize more than three dimensions, with a bit of cleverness we can still develop some intuitions about higher dimensions. We can extrapolate what we know about how things work in 3D, we can project higher-dimensional objects into lower dimensions, and so on. I think the same is true of extreme states of consciousness: even if we haven’t experienced such states ourselves, reading about them may allow us to begin to grok—at least a little—the sheer magnitude of what is possible.

The collection

Table of Contents

IWorth more than a lifetime

  1. 1 Heinrich Suso Any pain would be a small price
  2. 2 Ignatius Loyola One moment outweighs sixty years
  3. 3 Jacob Boehme A quarter-hour worth a university
  4. 4 Angela of Foligno “This whole world is full of God!”
  5. 5 Joseph Salmon “Nonentitized into the being of beings”

IISeconds that last a lifetime

  1. 6 R. M. Bucke A few seconds, never lost in 25 years
  2. 7 A clergyman on a hilltop “The less real of the two”
  3. 8 Richard Church An earthquake in a school classroom
  4. 9 Bernard Berenson Nothing dull ever again
  5. 10 Childbirth Ready to give away everything

IIIMore than a body can hold

  1. 11 M. E. in the Alps Four minutes, half an hour to recover
  2. 12 St Teresa of Ávila Disordered for hours, certain for years
  3. 13 Respondent 54 Electricity in the chest, and a mediocre poem
  4. 14 Tennyson, “Timbuctoo” The brain staggers

IVOrdinary people, ordinary places

  1. 15 “A” An ugly villa, and “there is something perfect”
  2. 16 Respondent 61 The bacterium and the universe at once
  3. 17 Respondent 26 You only find out afterwards that you were in heaven
  4. 18 Carlo Levi Bliss beside a deathbed
  5. 19 Marcel Proust The madeleine
  6. 20 Jacquetta Hawkes The camel caravan
  7. 21 C. P. Snow “Different in kind”
  8. 22 Arthur Koestler Atrocities shrink to nothing
  9. 23 Roger Bannister Barefoot on the sand

VTime collapses

  1. 24 Arnold Toynbee All of history on Buckingham Palace Road
  2. 25 C. G. Jung The world comes into being
  3. 26 Edward Gibbon Days lost in Rome
  4. 27 The monk and the lark A hundred years in one song

VIComing back

  1. 28 Emily Brontë The agony of return
  2. 29 “A sort of green light” Knowing everything, and it won’t translate
  3. 30 Sir Patrick Hastings Beyond anything known to the living

VIIJoy beyond what the body can bear

  1. 31 Charles G. Finney Waves of liquid love
  2. 32 Sarah Edwards A night worth more than a lifetime
  3. 33 Stephen H. Bradley Happiness he could scarcely contain
  4. 34 Henry Alline A night released from darkness

VIIIA world made new

  1. 35 David Brainerd Glory in a grove
  2. 36 Alphonse Ratisbonne The church that vanished
  3. 37 Jonathan Edwards The sweetness of thunder
  4. 38 Billy Bray A new man in a new world
  5. 39 An unnamed woman Woods filled with heavenly music
  6. 40 An Oxford graduate An unexpected afternoon of love

IXNature and the expansion of the self

  1. 41 John Trevor Heaven on the road through the hills
  2. 42 Henri-Frédéric Amiel Moments as spacious as the universe
  3. 43 Malwida von Meysenbug Rising as one imperishable
  4. 44 Walt Whitman Love as the structure of creation
  5. 45 An unnamed police officer Feet barely on the pavement

XAccounts of contemplative absorption

  1. 46 Al-Ghazali What study alone could never teach
  2. 47 St John of the Cross A delicious solitude
or share an experience of your own